Which area of verbal ability is an exception to the typical female advantage?

This is a preview. Log in through your library.

Abstract

The purpose of this article is to examine the evidence for sex differences in cognitive functioning and to review and evaluate evidence for hormonal, genetic, neuroanatomical, and cultural determinants of such differences. Inadequacies in the evidence for sex differences, such as underreporting of negative findings, failure to measure effect size, small sample sizes, etc., are noted. It is likely that sex hormones influence the organization and functioning of the brain. Sex differences in brain organization and functioning are discussed. In summary, the existence of sex differences in cognitive functioning is clear, but further research is needed to elucidate the determinants of these differences.

Journal Information

Distinguished by its international recognition since 1958, Human Development publishes theoretical contributions and integrative reviews of lines of research in psychological development within conceptual, historical, and methodological frameworks. Contributions serve to raise theoretical issues, flesh out interesting and potentially powerful ideas, and differentiate key constructs. Contributions come primarily from developmental psychology, but are welcome from other relevant disciplines.

Publisher Information

Karger Publishers is a worldwide publisher of scientific and medical content based in Basel, Switzerland. It is independent and family-led in the fourth generation by Chairwoman and Publisher Gabriella Karger. Karger has been continuously evolving, keeping pace with the current developments and shifts in research and publishing. The publishing house is dedicated to serving the information needs of the scientific community, clinicians and patients with publications of high-quality content and services in health sciences.

Rights & Usage

This item is part of a JSTOR Collection.
For terms and use, please refer to our Terms and Conditions
Human Development © 1980 S. Karger AG
Request Permissions

  • Which area of verbal ability is an exception to the typical female advantage?
    Access through your institution

Which area of verbal ability is an exception to the typical female advantage?

Which area of verbal ability is an exception to the typical female advantage?

Abstract

Previous research has sometimes claimed a female advantage on tasks of incidental memory. However, it is uncertain whether the sex difference was due to the incidental, or to the heavily verbal, nature of the tasks used, since women are known to have better verbal memory than men. The current study asked whether a female superiority would be found under less verbally-loaded conditions. No sex difference was found on two different pictorial tasks, both of which measured incidental memory for the content of complex scenes. In contrast, a female advantage was observed across both incidental and intentional conditions when easily labeled stimuli were used. This advantage was eliminated on the incidental condition when the effects of intentional verbal memory were controlled for. These findings strongly suggest that previous reports of a female advantage on incidental memory may have been due to the choice of verbalizable stimuli.

Cited by (31)

  • Learning in the navigational space: Age differences in a short-term memory for objects task

    2016, Learning and Individual Differences

    The ARSM task required immediate recall of visuospatial information presented in the navigational space for a brief period of time, whereas the VSRD (as a delayed spatial task for items presented in the near space) involved an effort of a static observer to keep in mind spatial items for a longer period of time. Some studies suggest that females may benefit from verbal strategies during the learning phase that would result in a more successful encoding (Alexander, Packard, & Peterson, 2002; Chipman & Kimura, 1998; Eals & Silverman, 1994). However, female superiority was rarely observed in tasks that involved navigation (Coluccia & Louse, 2004; Saucier, Lisoway, Green, & Elias, 2007).

  • 2012, Neuroscience Letters

    Presumably, this measuring system is more effective in males than in females, and results in an early detection of structural changes of objects. In turn, in the object-constructive task, females are more efficient when using the working memory component [4,10]. In summary, we have found out the gender-related differences at the early stage of visuo-spatial processing and a remarkable sensitivity of the parietal P1 peak amplitude in males only to the object structure changes, namely to the rotation of object details.

  • Sex differences in episodic memory among children with intractable epilepsy

    2009, Epilepsy and Behavior

    Research on sex differences in episodic memory is extensive, and where differences have been found, they indicate that women show an advantage in verbal memory, memory for object locations, and face recognition [1–3,7], whereas men show an advantage in visuospatial memory. Verbal memory tasks on which women excel include word recall and recognition [4–6], object recall [7], and story recall [8]. Although it has been hypothesized that this sex difference may be due to the female advantage in verbal abilities, rather than to a true advantage in verbal episodic memory [9], it has been demonstrated that the effect for verbal memory is obtained even when verbal ability is statistically controlled [10].

  • What grabs his attention but not hers? Estrogen correlates with neurophysiological measures of vocal change detection

    2008, Psychoneuroendocrinology

    Furthermore, a large number of behavioral studies found better verbal memory in women than in men (for a review see Kimura, 1999). Interestingly, the female memory advantage appears to be specific to intentional stimulus encoding, but does not show up if men and women are tested for incidental encoding (Chipman and Kimura, 1998). In line with the present results, this suggests that maintenance of attentional focus on the primary task is driving the observed sex effects.

Arrow Up and RightView all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Copyright © 1999 Published by Elsevier Inc.

In which of the following cognitive areas are gender differences the largest?

the gender differences are typically larger on mental rotation tasks than on other kinds of spatial tasks.

What is an exception to the general pattern of men's greater resource control?

controlling desirable goods, safety, health, and freedom. What is an exception to the general pattern of men's greater resource control? child custody.

Which of the following best describes the relationship between benevolent and hostile sexism quizlet?

What is the nature of the relationship between hostile sexism and benevolent sexism? Positive correlation: If one type is present in a society, so is the other. men are harmed by androcentrism alone and women by androcentrism, sexism, and subordination.